Greater Boston & South Shore Homeowners Insurance Buying Guide

What to know before you buy — and why working with an independent agent makes a difference.

We're glad you reached out.

Whether you own a city brownstone, a South Shore colonial, or a Boston condo, getting the right coverage starts with a conversation. Our team reviews submissions promptly and will follow up with next steps. In the meantime, here's what to keep in mind as you move through the

An independent agent gives you access to more options.

Unlike a captive agent who represents a single carrier, an independent agency works with multiple insurance companies — which means more choices and more flexibility to find coverage that fits your property and your situation. Sterling Insurance Group actively works in the Boston and South Shore markets and stays current on carrier availability, policy forms, and underwriting guidelines as they change. Look for proper Massachusetts property and casualty licensing and ongoing professional development when choosing who to work with.

The details of your property matter more than you might expect.

Properties across Boston, Hingham, and the South Shore vary widely — from historic brownstones and city condominiums to waterfront homes on the coast. The following features can each affect what carriers and coverage options are available to you:

  • Age of the home and condition of the roof

  • Type of structure — single family, condominium, or multifamily

  • Proximity to the coast or tidal water, in feet

  • Distance from the nearest fire department or fire hydrant

  • Usage of the home, including any short or long-term rental activity or business use

  • Quality of construction and notable architectural features

  • Flood zone designation and flood risk, particularly for coastal and low-lying neighborhoods

  • Special features such as swimming pools, docks, or detached structures

The more detail you can share upfront, the better positioned we are to bring you relevant options quickly.

Condo owners: your unit policy and your building's master policy work together.

If you own a condo, your condominium association carries a master policy that typically covers the building structure — but the scope of that coverage varies by association. Your individual unit policy is designed to work alongside it, covering your interior, personal property, and personal liability. Reviewing the master policy alongside your unit policy is a helpful starting point for any coverage conversation, and our team is happy to walk through both with you.

Read your policy — especially the fine print.

It's important to note that the coverage amount for dwelling coverage is typically unrelated to the market value of the property. Dwelling coverage is based on the cost to rebuild or repair the property in the event of damage or destruction due to covered perils. It takes into account factors such as the square footage, construction materials, architectural features, and labor costs required to restore the property to its pre-damage condition. The Vineyard has much higher costs of construction than most mainland communities due to its remote nature and high cost of living. It’s important to get this value accurate to avoid co-insurance penalties.

Rebuild costs and market value are not the same thing.

Dwelling coverage is based on the estimated cost to rebuild or repair your home after a covered loss — not what you paid for it or what it's worth today. Boston and the South Shore have some of the highest construction costs in New England, driven by labor, materials, and the complexity of older and historic properties. Working through this number carefully is an important part of the quoting process, and something our team pays close attention to on every submission.

Starting early gives you better options.

Some Boston and South Shore properties require additional underwriting time depending on the carrier and coverage type. The earlier you start, the more room there is to compare options across the market. If you're on a tight timeline, let us know — we can typically move quickly to find available options, though a broader market review always produces better results when time allows.

Ready to move forward? Our team will be in touch shortly. If you have questions in the meantime, call us directly or reply to your confirmation email — we're happy to help.

We are excited to welcome
you to Sterling Insurance Group.

  • “Everyone at Sterling Insurance has been a pleasure to deal with--professional, responsive, happy to walk through options and answer all my questions. Great company and highly recommended!"

    Warren Z.

  • “I've consistently noted excellent, prompt communication and honest responses to detailed questions. It was quite a refreshing experience, one that convinced me to become a new customer."

    John P.

  • “I have had the pleasure to work with Rich and Libby for 10+ years. They are extremely professional, knowledgeable, hard working, and access the strongest insurance companies in the industry."

    Phillip M.